New Mexico Daily Lobo
URL: http://www.dailylobo.com/index.php/article/2011/05/lion_king_cartoon_merits_apology
Current Date: Thu, 24 May 2012 10:40:32 -0600
Possibly Related:
‘Lion King’ cartoon merits apology
Over the past two days, the Daily Lobo has received numerous complaints about a cartoon that ran in our Opinion section on Tuesday.
The political cartoon alluded to a memorable scene from the Disney movie, “The Lion King,” in which Rafiki announces Simba’s birth. Except in this case, President Barack Obama was cast as Rafiki, and in place of Simba was Osama bin Laden’s severed head.
Regrettably, this cartoon offended the African-American community — along with many others — who interpreted Obama’s representation as racist. For this oversight, I sincerely apologize.
To clear the record, I approved publication of the cartoon.
It was not published with the intent to perpetuate stereotypes, or infer African-American students are in any way inferior.
Someone in my position should be more culturally sensitive, and I and the staff plan to remedy the situation.
I already talked with African-American students and African American Students Services. Furthermore, the Daily Lobo is in talks concerning sensitivity training for the staff with African-American groups on campus.
In addition, we will continue to keep our doors, as well as the Opinion section, open for anyone who wishes to participate in the discourse.
That said, I would be remiss if I didn’t also take this chance to defend the paper for the less–than-glamorous attention we’ve received.
First, it should be noted that the Daily Lobo hires students from all walks of life. Anyone who walks through our door gets a chance to write.
It must be made clear that we are not barring African-Americans from joining our staff, but few have applied, save for one freelance reporter who writes regularly.
We want that to change, and so, again, we are asking that minority students consider writing for the Daily Lobo. You don’t have to be a journalism major, and you don’t need previous experience writing for a paper. If you want to write and are willing to work hard, come in and we will teach you.
Second, the Daily Lobo has, in the past, strived to work with African-American student organizations. Our previous editor, Pat Lohmann, worked with the organizations to educate our reporters about cultural sensitivity. He set a date with the group and mandated that every staffer attend.
Unfortunately, no one from African American Student Services showed up. We are actively trying to set another meeting, but I want to make it clear that the Daily Lobo has not ignored the organization.
In fact, we pioneered a column unique to New Mexico, The Afro-American Experience, specifically to help illustrate the challenges and problems African-Americans encounter. No other paper in the state has ever done this, and we are not trying to pat ourselves on the back, but would like to remind people about the efforts we have taken to highlight difficulties unique to African-Americans in this state.
Third, we must make it clear that we did not run the cartoon with the intent to be racist. We saw the cartoon as an interpretation of Osama bin Laden’s death and the American celebration along with it. We saw the cartoon as a symbol of the twisted nature of American pride and thought it would provoke interesting, not racist, discussion. Since we can only speculate as to the intent of the cartoon, I contacted the artist, Hajo de Reijer.
“It wasn’t my intention to be racist. And it will never be,” he said. “U.S. President Barack Obama tweaked Donald Trump at the annual White House correspondents’ dinner over the fuss he made over his place of birth. Obama showed the opening scene from the movie ‘Lion King,’ showing baby Simba being born to his Lion King father.”
De Reijer said his cartoon was simply a reflection of a current event. In full disclosure, De Reijer is from the Netherlands and is not necessarily attuned to the racial undertones of such a depiction of Obama in America.
We bring this up not to justify the cartoon’s content, but to try to foster understanding of our editorial decision to run it.
In short, we would like to use this opportunity to again apologize to the African-American community, as well as anyone else offended by the cartoon. We will continue to strive to be culturally sensitive in the present and future, and we encourage all students on the campus to express their voice through our paper.
We understand the severity of the situation, and rather than brushing it aside, we would like to learn from it so this oversight won’t happen again.
Thank for your time and consideration, Daily Lobo readers, and good luck in finals.
Sincerely,
Christopher Quintana
Editor-in-Chief



19 comments
Will
Flag this comment
As a former Lobo managing editor who made his share of missteps, I’d like to commend you for facing this situation squarely. Your response is thoughtful and clearly heartfelt.
I’m sure you will hear many more perspectives now, which is part of what makes the Lobo such a great learning experience.
Read more
This part of the job is one of the hardest, but it’s the part of greatest service to you and the community. All the best to you as you do this hard work.
Bush "The Chimp"
Flag this comment
Didn’t the media print endless cartoons of another President, George W. Bush, as “The Chimp” and still do? How many of you complained about that “racist depiction?” I bet you’d say, “But those were funny!”
There is also an institutional wide “racism and cultural insensitivity” concerning Jews and Israel including letters allowed to be printed by these same editors! Shall we search the archives for anti-Jewish cartoons? No letters and cartoons are allowed to paint Muslims in the same tone!
Read more
Any criticism of these anti-Semitic attacks and Bush cartoons will be countered with “a free speech issue” and the ACLU would defend those rights. So, where is the ACLU now? This is right up their alley!
kmakavou
Flag this comment
This denial of “free speech” will only lead to censorship and denial of any comments pro’s or con’s as already is evident concerning “The celebration of justice” comments that are not being allowed!
Jeff Spicole
Flag this comment
I agree with Bush, liberal editors will apologize for muslims and blacks. Flotilla happy liberals will use the race card through 2012. Blacks should be more concerned with their own extinction through abortion than cartoons. I am sure UNM liberal instructors will also complain osama bin ladin should have been brought to trial in NYC. sic
Daily Lobo Supporter
Flag this comment
Great letter Chris! I agree that the Afro-America community should not be so sensitive or undermine the First Amendment of the Constitution. Obviously the intent was not to be racist as the main theme of the cartoon is obvious: Osama’s severed head!! The cartoon was also accompanied by an article explaining the “hate begets hate” view that many people take. How can the Daily Lobo be racist while promoting peace? None of the people involved in this uproar mentioned that fact! I personally believe that the African-American students involved were just looking for a fight and jumped at this opportunity to accuse the Daily Lobo of being a racist paper. I attended the rally held by African-American Student Services yesterday and by the end I was rolling my eyes. I believe these people don’t want to be treated equally… They want to be treated better than equally and special treatment is not something I support. White people are sorry for the past and our younger generations no longer see black as inferior or even different. What these people don’t realize is their actions are not encouraging change. They are encouraging white people to view black people as black. In essence they encouraging exactly what they do not want! We will always have hate groups and racist people but the Daily Lobo is not one of them and it is unfair for the African-American community to shout lies to the press for attention! BUT, this is just my opinion… thank god for free speech!
Bourne
Flag this comment
Keep being apologists for racism, Bush, Jeff, et al. Your 1950’s insights into race relations are highly relevant and sure do paint you as esteemed and scholarly gentlemen!
Tina
Flag this comment
Dear Supporter, very well writen and stated! I agree totally!
phillip howel
Flag this comment
Students, your future is burdened with a personal Federal debt of $46,000; manufacturing in this country is disappearing faster than a leaf in a winter wind, the Constitution is being undermined and you are worried about a stupid cartoon.
Get a grip on reality, focus on what really matters. Your BA will get you a good job at Mickey D’s who just hired 40-50 or so thousand people if we do not stop the loss of manufacturing jobs. We need to build refineries and drill for gas and oil to provide the jobs for engineering & geology students; the blue collar jobs that need MBA grads to management them.
Read more
Spain’s experiment with solar & wind proved the costs are greater than producing electricity with fossil fuels and result in a loss of jobs.
Students, your future isn’t in a cartoon, it is in learning the truth, honest facts about where the money to pay the salary you want & need to provide a decent quality of life for you and your family will come from. What will your life be like in 2021 if the national debt- your Federal debt is $56,000? What will you do to earn a living- not an existence- if another 15,000,000 manufacturing jobs go to other countries. Think you want to work in India, Mexico? China has plenty of people, they will not allow you in to work.
Focus on what is real.
Alwaysright
Flag this comment
OUTRAGEOUS!! Monkeys are caring intelligent creatures, and should demand an inmediate appology for depicting them with a lower life form.
docsavage
Flag this comment
I didn’t think it was racist either. But then I never saw The Lion King. Now I know the connection with the correspondents dinner it still seems like a bad idea. Even someone from the Netherlands should know better. Does De Reijer commonly paint swastikas on his cartoon Jews? Notice I said ‘a bad idea’ & not ‘racist’. But until words like ‘ignorant,’ ‘insenstive,’ ‘depraved’ once more refer to concepts that Americans find humiliating, then I’m afraid racist will have to do. And just for you guys hollering to ‘get over it’: Hey, we already knew you were white, no need to crow about it….
CM
Flag this comment
And these are the same people that voted for Obama only due to his skin color? That’s as racist as it gets unless you went to a church that taught Black Liberation Theology!
What would MLK say?
Flag this comment
“Those who cry the most about racism, are usually the biggest racists since they want to do to others as they think others are doing to them even if they are not!” Martin Luther King
These groups and their members will then take a racist revenge against the Lobo editor and anyone who dares question them making them the real racists in this case!
WW
Flag this comment
I saw the cartoon and it never occured to me that anyone would be offended but here they are! Can’t they take a joke? They haven’t been to a Chris Rock comedy act where the n-word is every other word? Every black comedian I’ve ever heard uses it freely and so where are these groups denouncing the use of a word they want to ban from the English language? Whoopi freely said the word and it was Hasselbeck who was crying having to hear it so many times! Where’s the outrage from blacks? I recall an article from this year that a group here at UNM was trying to ban the word and yet the only ones saying it are blacks! This was a cartoon that had nothing to do with race equating monkeys to Obama! When the group ever stands up to the use of the n-word by blacks themselves, I will join them!
delijdewolfe
Flag this comment
I highly, HIGHLY recommend everyone read “Losing the Race” by John H. McWhorter. It is highly informative and will give you a far better understanding of the racial divide.
ps- the image didn’t offend me.
Chopski
Flag this comment
You sadden me for tucking tail and apologizing for something that wasnt racist… unless you do your best to read something into it… nut up and stand your ground
docsavage
Flag this comment
@delijdewolfe – what tickles me is white people thinking they have any say about the African-American experience … except maybe ‘sorry, dude!’
jack
Flag this comment
We have a generation of young people who actually believe they have a right to not be offended. This is a perfect example of what happens when students view everything through the lens of what they perceive to be their victimization. We are all perfectly balkanized now. And then to have others bow to the alter of cultural sensitivity training in response is sickening. A university is supposed to make you uncomfortable. It is not supposed to be a sanitized bubble where nobody is offended and unicorns and glitter rule the day as opposed to a provocative challenge to whatever it is you believe. Every time something like this happens, it highlights the complete and utter failure of the postmodern university.
Jack
Flag this comment
And to docsavage, your comment reflects perfectly the fallacy of the ad hominem attack. If fosters this result: “No one can be given credit for speaking from genuine moral or political conviction anymore; everyone can be dismissed or derided with a nod to their personal background. This may be the logical end of identity politics, where ultimately we’re each locked inside whatever little box we check, tiny caucuses of one, and common ground is impossible”.
(Adam Serwer). I can only hope that the era of identity politics that has been cultivated by the university for decades and that so many of you subscribe to will come to end soon.
Stephen
Flag this comment
THE CRY OF RACISM regarding the Obama cartoon It is totally ridiculous! Obama himself showed an excerpt from the movie the Lion King during a recent press conference. It is a sad but true fact that many will use the cry of racism when they seek to get attention. In my HUMBLE opinion the true racism lies in opening a column specifically for black students to write about their unique struggles. Will there also be a column for white students to cry aloud about their unique struggles? Oh of course not! And in THAT lies the true seed of racism. Now censorship is alive and well in the Daily Lobo and I for one may have to stop reading it. I agree with the daily lobo supporter who wrote, “believe these people don’t want to be treated equally… They want to be treated better than equally and special treatment is not something I support. White people are sorry for the past and our younger generations no longer see black as inferior or even different. What these people don’t realize is their actions are not encouraging change. They are encouraging white people to view black people as black. In essence they encouraging exactly what they do not want! “ Well said. I realize your appology may be an attempt to try and stop riots and racial crys of prejudice but in the long run these protesters are not truly seeking equal treatment but are seeking SPECIAL treatment alotted to no other racial or reigious group in our community. God bless them and God bless freedom of the press. It is a sad state of affairs when our local college paper can not be a free press.
Comments are closed for this item.