Giant Book Sale

Article Tools

Use the form below to share this article via email.


Your name:

Your email:

To email:

Message:

Possibly Related:

Garbiso: Colleague fabricated claims

Last updated: 12/01/09 12:03am

Mute for nearly three months, Shannon Garbiso is no longer tongue-tied about her role in investigating a Sept. 20 altercation involving first-year head coach Mike Locksley and former wide receivers coach J.B. Gerald.

The Athletics representative, who did the initial inquiry into the incident, denied a Daily Lobo report in which a former UNM colleague and decade-long friend, Maria Garcia, claimed Garbiso’s job was in jeopardy.

Garbiso, who declined a phone interview, said in an e-mail that Garcia portrayed the information she shared with her in the wrong light.

“I feel that friends do not take notes during conversations, nor do they speak to reporters on your behalf, when I specifically directed her not to,” Garbiso said. “I feel betrayed … This is about someone falsely representing me.”

Point by point, Garbiso contended that she never expressed concerns to former UNM Human Resources Consultant Garcia that her job was in danger, nor was she upset with Vice President of Human Resources Helen Gonzales for the way she was portrayed at a Nov. 3 news conference, in which Gonzales brought up questions about Garbiso’s qualifications to conduct investigations.

“I am not, nor was I, angry with Helen Gonzales or Paul Krebs,” she said. “There is no smear campaign. The assertion that I fear for my job is a flat-out lie. Not once have I felt my employment in athletics has been threatened. I enjoy working for Paul Krebs and very much enjoy the people I work with in the Athletics Department.”
In an interview with the Daily Lobo on Saturday, Garcia — who has a pending unrelated lawsuit against the University for pregnancy discrimination — said she had four phone conversations with Garbiso, in which Garbiso made statements to the contrary.

Monday, Garbiso acknowledged that she spoke with Garcia on Nov. 9 for the first time in nearly a year — but that Garcia called her first. Garcia said she did call Garbiso first and left a voice mail, which Garbiso returned soon after.

Among the most important claims, Garcia said Garbiso told her she did not destroy her notes, and, instead, handed over her notes to Gonzales — an allegation Garbiso disputes.

In clarifying, Garbiso said, “And, (as) has been stated before, I destroyed the notes of my interviews with the assistant coaches. I did this myself.”

When asked why she disposed of her notes, Garbiso responded: “We were gathering information about what happened. It was not an inquiry into an allegation of battery. As we have said all along, my notes were informal and unofficial. They were not sworn statements.”

Her comments stand in stark contrast to Garcia’s, who spoke on behalf of Garbiso, after she said Garbiso was advised to remain silent about everything pertaining to her initial inquiry of the Sept. 20 altercation.

At no point, Garbiso said, did she consider filing a complaint with Human Resources or the Office of Equal Opportunity — something Garcia said the two discussed over the phone.

Not surprisingly, Garcia said, Garbiso has chosen to deny everything she spoke about. Standing by what she previously stated to the Daily Lobo, Garcia countered that Garbiso did, in fact, voice her dissatisfaction with Gonzales over the phone, all while reiterating that Garbiso feared for her job.

“That she wasn’t angry with Helen is 100 percent false,” Garcia said. “She told me several times that she was angry with Helen. … She doesn’t want to lose her job. That’s what pays her bills. That’s what’s taking care of her and her family. She’s not going to say that it’s going to possibly put her in the line of fire. She has to deny what I’m saying.”

Garcia added that Garbiso is likely being pressured by University officials to discredit her claims.

“I really feel for her,” Garcia said. “I knew there was a huge possibility that she was going to be very angry with me. That isn’t going to hurt my feelings. I know what she said, and she knows what she said. I stand by everything that I told you.

I did not, in any way, try to embellish what she told me. She’s in a seriously sticky position, because not only does she have Krebs, Gonzales and legal and Schmidly telling her you need to write to (the reporter) and tell him that everything that was said is completely untrue. She’s overwhelmed. She’s getting bombarded.”

In their conversations, Garbiso made it explicitly clear to Garcia that she was not to speak to the media on her behalf, she said in an e-mail.

“During our phone conversation, I told Ms. Garcia that she was not allowed to speak for me,” she said. “She does not represent me.”

Conversely, Garcia said that she disclosed to Garbiso that she intended to speak to the media about their conversations, a token Garcia said Garbiso appreciated, because she could not speak to the media herself.

The Daily Lobo contacted Garbiso via e-mail over the weekend about this issue and also on Nov. 1 and Nov. 2 seeking comment on the findings of her initial inquiry.
Garbiso was asked to tell her side of the story, but she redirected questions to administration.

“I’ve shared every detail of what I’ve heard and understood to have happened with Paul Krebs and the University’s human resources,” she said in an e-mail. “So if you have further questions, please ask Helen Gonzales, the University’s VP of Human Resources.”

Garcia said Garbiso is in a precarious predicament, and she stands by her friend, no matter what happens.

“We’ve been friends for a really long time,” she said. “And it made me very angry, and it made me hurt for her that … they found it so easy to throw her under the bus.”

Pat Lohmann contributed to this story.

Published December 1, 2009 in News

76 comments



Another Garbiso Co-worker

December 1, 2009 at 12:53 AM
Flag this comment

C’mon Shannon! You have told me too many times to count how much you despise Helen over the last several years! I don’t know what you said to Cruz only you and her really know what was shared but, I DO KNOW THAT YOU CAN’T STAND HELEN! AND WHY WOULD YOU SPECIFICALLY TELL CRUZ NOT TO TALK TO THE MEDIA ABOUT YOU AND HER SHARED IN CONVERSATION IF WHAT YOU WERE TELLING HER WOULDN’T SHED A NEGATIVE LIGHT ON YOU? I’ve known Cruz longer than I’ve known you and she is a reliable , forthright and credible human being. Until now I thought you were too! As HR Employees we are all often put into very uncomfortable positions by the people we work for (our supervisor’s) and the information we have access to on all UNM employees as a product of our job duties when we are expected to follow UNM Policy and Procedures while also accommodating our supervisor’s wishes which are often not consistent with UNM Policies and Procedures. We can not allow ourselves or our loyalty to our work responsibilities as HR Employees to be manipulated and coerced to the blatant disregard of the wishes of this Administration’s self imposed mandates. YOU WOULD NEVER DESTROY ANY DOCUMENTS OF A PERSONNEL EMPLOYEE RELATED MATTER EVEN IF IT IS JUST AN INQUIRY THAT YOU WERE DIRECTED TO DO BY YOUR BOSS PAUL KREBS!!!! I truly like you Shannon …but, now that you have decided to go to the “dark side” and weave yourself into this mess and in light of the fact that YOU are actually stating by YOUR OWN WORDS (FINALLY!) that you destroyed those notes. . .then you need to be replaced. We all make mistakes and bad choices but, not to the level of your trained knowledge in Human Resources to destroy documents! Now if you were directed to destroy these documents and your being advised to only tell the “half truth” then that would be more consistent with the Shannon Garbiso I know! And if that is so ….speak out now before you go down with them! WHAT A HORRIBLE PLACE THIS UNIVERSITY HAS BECOME TO WORK FOR!!! I STILL LOVE THESE KIDS (STUDENTS) AND MOST OF MY CO-WORKERS, THE FACULTY & STAFF BUT THIS REVELATION IS MOST DEPRESSING!
I am an HR Professional, and for the record to every V.P., including my supervisor Helen Gonzales, President Schmidly, and the Regents . . . I WILL NOT BE MADE TO FEAR YOU! AND I WILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO EVER MANIPULATE ME TO FURTHER YOUR PERSONAL AGENDAS OR CLEAN UP YOUR MESS!
I AM A PROUD UNM EMPLOYEE AND THIS UNIVERSITY BELONGS TO ME , MY COLLEAGUES , MY NEIGHBORS . . .AND MY CHILDREN!!!!
I will make myself known and accountable to the UNM Employees I proudly serve and assist and I will not sit back and allow corruption and cronyism to prevail in my presence!


lazo

December 1, 2009 at 1:13 AM
Flag this comment

Something is rotten here at UNM.


Another Garbiso Co-Worker2

December 1, 2009 at 1:39 AM
Flag this comment

This article creates more questions than answers! Where was all this denial by you Shannon when Cruz went before the board of regents on Nov. 10th (the day after you spoke with her by phone) protesting the Administration’s depiction of you at their media conference as being incapable of conducting valid and credible interviews with regards to your notes that they produced to the media and asking for an indepedent investigation of the Regents? just silence is what you contributed then! oh! I forgot this is the first you’ve heard of it? …I’m sure!
Paul Krebs admits that he directed you to compile and obtain the information from the asst. coaches present at the Sept. 20 incident/altercation . . . if it isn’t about a “battery” then what info. did he direct you to obtain? Sworn statements? is that the new angle? we all know that you’re not a lawyer shannon! Maybe you should retain a lawyer and quit listening to those clowns/court jesters up at Scholes Hall who call themselves legal counsel. FYI ….I’m not admitting any “official” affiliation with “Another Garbiso Co-worker” who previously posted before me. . .and you can’t prove that I know them!
Shannon you just aren’t credible at this point at all ! and we have all known for sometime in UNM HR that Maria has a lawsuit against the University for pregnancy discrimination and from what I’ve heard (official rumor!) she should probably go public with it! Of course she (Maria) has handled herself with integrity in not disclosing her personal dispute with the university unlike others (Do you hear me Sylvia?) who have been confrontational and gone to the media and have gotten paid! If you do hear me Sylvia could I get your comped B-ball tickets to the Cal game?
Time to go to bed… lot’s of HR gossip tomorrow(I mean today!) to discuss around the HR water cooler! Thanks for letting me know of this article “Another Garbiso Co-worker” ..I “officially” don’t know you though!


Faith

December 1, 2009 at 5:34 AM
Flag this comment

That she wasn’t angry with Helen is 100 percent false,” Garcia said. “She told me several times that she was angry with Helen. … She doesn’t want to lose her job. That’s what pays her bills. That’s what’s taking care of her and her family. She’s not going to say that it’s going to possibly put her in the line of fire. She has to deny what I’m saying.”

Garcia added that Garbiso is likely being pressured by University officials to discredit her claims.

Read more …

Everyone is always lying on the UNM administrators, yeah right. Garbiso said she feared losing her job, that is what keeps people from telling the truth about this manipulative corrupt administration.


AthleticsAdminemployee

December 1, 2009 at 10:50 AM
Flag this comment

The University should rename our dept. “damage control operations”! Why is the administration now allowing Shannon to send an e-mail response to the LOBO that is highly suspect in it’s content like “I am not,nor was I, angry with Helen Gonzales or Paul Krebs” and “They were not sworn statements”, and especially “I’ve shared every detail of what I’ve heard and understood to have happened with Paul Krebs and the University’s human resources” . . .you haven’t shared squat! none of us have ! but we know the assistant coaches that are going to resign at the end of their contracts next month will! I will state that I fear losing my job , at least my position within this department if I even so much as lightly wince in pain to the media. This e-mail response from Shannon sounds like another vigorously contrived and invented response by Kathleen Hessert having a mental threesome with UNM Legal Counsel Ira Bolnick and Krebs or maybe it was a full swap including Helen too!
Why doesn’t Shannon come full forward and do some interviews with the media ? Too late! her integrity and suspicion of her involvement in this cover up would be too big of a risk for the administration. . .they will not allow it! Hey Raymond! and the rest of the Regents heard enough “new stuff” yet? Of course you haven’t you want to discredit everyone ! how pathetic of you to try and smear the character of a student reporter at the University’s daily newspaper and now you’re attempting to discredit the integrity of Maria Garcia because you fear what she has been told by Shannon. The PR armor is cracking ! Good job Isaac we all appreciate your continued efforts to blow this thing wide open!


LoboLouie

December 1, 2009 at 10:58 AM
Flag this comment

I’m not really lobo louie but, what the hey everyone else is lying at UNM!
I wish all of these supposed unm employees posting comments on here would grow a pair and really come forward instead of hiding behind their posted comments! The way I see it the only people that have put their *sses on line with their statements are Maria Garcia and this news reporter Isaac Avilucea.


Jerry

December 1, 2009 at 11:01 AM
Flag this comment

“Faith” is right lying for the administration is required in our job descriptions!


Karen

December 1, 2009 at 11:04 AM
Flag this comment

At what training seminar do they teach human resources employees to effectively and efficiently destroy documents? How were these notes destroyed? paper shredder?


FBseasontcktholdernomore

December 1, 2009 at 11:09 AM
Flag this comment

WOW! another weak attempt to diffuse the public’s interest in your cover up! She said She said , no i won’t do an interview! , no i won’t tattle on daddy and momma! i’m a grown woman but I love daddy, and momma will answer all your questions you have for me!


Libby

December 1, 2009 at 11:13 AM
Flag this comment

Karen , that would be the training seminar led by you guessed it! UNM HR! But, if you ask them directly they will “officially deny that the seminar exists” you know, attorney client privilege!


RealityUNM

December 1, 2009 at 11:40 AM
Flag this comment

How about somebody pitch this circus as a made for tv reality series! Maybe we could syndicate this and put some of the money that we will be paying to settle Gerald’s upcoming lawsuit and all the other discrimination lawsuits that UNM is now facing! What a hilarious bunch of idiots! Go Aggies!


Areyousure

December 1, 2009 at 11:45 AM
Flag this comment

Oh Shannon, My dear dear Shannon. You have lost total perception of the reality that exists beyond the Athletics Department. What promises have they made you? What do you think the end result of this entire situation is going to be?
I feel for you. I will pray for you.


Alfordfriend

December 1, 2009 at 11:49 AM
Flag this comment

just in case any of you might be wondering Coach Alford and most of the rest of the coaches for our sports programs are tired of this garbage and know that their ability to get committed recruits is suffering because of all of this as well!
Cut Locksley and Krebs loose before they take down the whole ship


Isittrue

December 1, 2009 at 11:54 AM
Flag this comment

Shannon Garbiso is alive? Really? are you sure it was really her that responded to Maria Garcia’s contentions? I don’t believe it because Schmidly, Krebs, and Gonzales have not stated “officially” through Susan Mckinsey that a Shannon Garbiso actually exists at UNM Athletics. I will wait for the Custodian of records to confirm this new revelation in about 5 months as I just submitted my request for official department records this morning!


The Truth

December 1, 2009 at 11:57 AM
Flag this comment

Please, anyone with information step forward. I’m sure this Isaac fellow is willing to follow up on any leads. sports@dailylobo.com


Gonzoknows

December 1, 2009 at 12:01 PM
Flag this comment

What funny fodder! I am so entertained, I want more of this Gossip Girl! I love you Isaac! If you’re not gay,will you marry me ? even if you are would your boyfriend mind? This is the best stuff I have ever read in the Lobo!!! Please tell me you have more! Really , sarcasm aside do your thing boy! Fair and balanced , Maria yesterday Shannon today what can people complain about?
You are doing a great job! Keep it up!


Anyone

December 1, 2009 at 12:05 PM
Flag this comment

Is there anyone that believes Shannon Garbiso? These comments are clearly not in support of her. I can understand why she hasn’t said anything until now and I’m not really sure that the e-mail referenced in this article are her words as others have questioned as well.


LiarsU

December 1, 2009 at 12:09 PM
Flag this comment

The sky is still blue isn’t it? I’m wondering what color it is over at campus , I’d hate to ask any of the Administration for fear of any of their answers. 2012? Our world ended here at the university 2009 … overachievers we are


OMG

December 1, 2009 at 12:13 PM
Flag this comment

I lied better in the 3rd grade about not doing my homework! What are they smoking down at Athletics? Maria Garcia hit a nerve didn’t she?


firstyearstudent

December 1, 2009 at 12:14 PM
Flag this comment

I need a drink. . . truth syrup anyone?


Staffer

December 1, 2009 at 12:21 PM
Flag this comment

Gonzoknows must be one of the administrators in question. What a poor attempt at trying to disparage Isaac. The truth will come out and you will all go down. I can’t wait because all of you deserve to pay for all you have done to ruin our University.


What was she thinking

December 1, 2009 at 12:21 PM
Flag this comment

In response to the article written about Shannon Garbiso the UNM allowance for her to respond to it gives it credibility in light of the fact that the administration’s position to “zip it” has now been breached. Make no mistake about it, administration be it Krebs , Gonzales , legal staff , pr consultant and Schmidly all have their hands in this so called e-mail response to the Lobo by Shannon Garbiso.
I hope to hear a follow up interview of Garcia and Gonzales on this . Any phone records available to corroborate either side?


Lunchbreak

December 1, 2009 at 12:24 PM
Flag this comment

Any chance of promoting a Garcia vs. Garbiso undercard to the upcoming Holly Holmes fight at Isleta?


Aboutfriends

December 1, 2009 at 12:27 PM
Flag this comment

Friends don’t let friends drive drunk . . . or blatantly lie and participate in a damaging cover up. Get the bigger picture Ms. Garbiso and forget about your selfish concerns at the Athletics Department. Resign your position! You are as incompentant as Krebs and Gonzales says you are!


Ahug4Shannon

December 1, 2009 at 12:33 PM
Flag this comment

What would any of you do if you were in Shannon Garbiso’s position? really would you just come out and tell the truth? You are all hypocrits , you would do what you had to do to save your job too! I’m not so sure that we are all not being taken on a ride by Garcia and Garbiso because if you really look at it Garbiso hasn’t said anything until now and she is certainly not trusted by Krebs or Gonzales at this point because both Garbiso and Garcia admit to talking and in essence Garbiso is now fully protected by these actions because the University wouldn’t dare take action against her now , can you say retaliation lawsuit cha ching!

Comments are closed for this item.